Skip to content

Baked fresh each morning — popular items can sell out. Call ahead for today's selection.

Cedar Key Island Bakery logo

Cedar Key, Florida

Fresh-Baked Memories on Cedar Key

Step inside a family-owned island bakery where old family recipes, fresh ingredients, and a warm welcome come together. From handmade pies and morning cake donuts to decorated cakes and seasonal favorites, everything is made with the kind of care you can taste.

The bakery case filled with rows of fresh cake donuts, glazed, frosted and topped with candies

Family-Owned • Baked Fresh Daily • Made in Cedar Key

Hours & location

Today · Wednesday
7:30 AM – 2:00 PM
MondayClosedTuesdayClosedWednesday7:30 AM – 2:00 PMThursday7:30 AM – 7:00 PMFriday7:30 AM – 7:00 PMSaturday7:30 AM – 7:00 PMSundayClosed
Where to find us
315 2nd Street
Cedar Key, FL 32625

(352) 325-3750

Get Directions

Hours can change with the season and around island events. Please call (352) 325-3750 to confirm today's hours.

Everything is baked in small batches, so favorites can sell out before closing. Calling ahead is the surest way to get what you came for.

Signature favorites

Made Here, Not Shipped In

No reheated, mass-produced desserts pretending to be homemade. Our bakery case is filled with family recipes and small-batch favorites prepared with care.

A bakery tray of cake donuts with swirled rainbow glazes, beside donuts topped with chocolate drizzle and candies
Available TodayToday's Donuts

Fresh Cake Donuts

Mixed, cut and fried in the morning. The batch is small, so the selection changes with the day.

A golden, flaky hand pie with fruit filling and a white icing drizzle
Available TodayPies

Handmade Pies

Rolled by hand using a family crust recipe that has stood the test of time. Whole pies and slices when available.

PreorderCakes & Cheesecakes

Family Cheesecake

Our distinctive cheesecake, made from a recipe that reached our family through German relatives.

Available TodayCookies & Breads

Banana Bread

A recipe that reaches back to the years following World War II. Baked in loaves, best while still warm.

Trays of pink and green macarons with a chalk sign reading Cedar Key Lime and Raspberry Macarons
Available TodayCookies & Breads

Cookies & Daily Treats

Small-batch cookies and whatever else came out of the oven that morning. Ask what's in the case today.

PreorderCakes & Cheesecakes

Custom Cakes

Decorated cakes for birthdays, reunions and gatherings. Planned with you by phone or inquiry form.

Quoted per order

Easter donuts on a tray, frosted in bright colors and topped with pink and yellow marshmallow bunnies
SeasonalSeasonal Favorites

Seasonal Favorites

Holiday pies and seasonal baking, announced ahead of time on our bakery list.

Daily selection varies, and favorites can sell out. Pricing changes with the day's baking. Please call (352) 325-3750 for today's prices.

Close-up of a chocolate-glazed donut drizzled with peanut butter icing

A little time travel

Some Flavors Take You Home

We want a visit to Cedar Key Island Bakery to feel like more than a stop for dessert. It should feel like stepping back in time—when a slice of apple pie could remind you of your mother's kitchen and a fresh donut was still made that morning. We believe good food and good memories belong together.

From the recipe box

Handwritten cards, still in use.

Our family

Family Recipes Found Their Way to an Island

Our family's bakery story began years ago in Indiana, where we created a country-kitchen bakery built around personal service and homemade food. Life eventually brought our family to Cedar Key. When plans changed during 2020, the old recipes came back out, and we began baking from home. The community's response helped that small beginning grow into the bakery you can visit today.

Some recipes have traveled through several generations and several branches of the family. Our pie crust has stood the test of time. Our banana bread recipe reaches back to the years following World War II. Our distinctive cheesecake recipe came to the family through German relatives who once operated a restaurant in Hollywood, California. Every recipe carries a story.

Read Our Story
Smiling behind the counter at Cedar Key Island Bakery, above a full case of fresh donutsHand-braided pastry dough filled with fruit, ready for the oven

Our island

More Than a Stop—Part of Cedar Key

Cedar Key is our home. We are raising a family here, building a business here, and planning to stay. Like the island itself, our story includes perseverance, rebuilding, and neighbors helping neighbors. We believe a rising tide lifts every boat, and every visitor who discovers Cedar Key helps our whole community.

Make the bakery part of your Cedar Key day.

Cedar Key Seafood Festival

Island-wide weekend downtown. Expect a busy bakery case.

Pirate Invasion

A family favorite on the waterfront.

Old Florida Celebration of the Arts

Artists fill the park for the weekend.

Festival weekends are busy on the island. Call ahead if you have your heart set on something.

Custom orders

Planning Something Special?

Ask us about decorated cakes, family gatherings, birthdays, corporate orders, reunions, and other large orders. Because everything is made by a small family team, advance notice helps us give your order the attention it deserves.

Follow along

See What Came Out of the Oven Today

We share the bakery case, seasonal treats and island news on Facebook and Instagram. Come say hello.

Get Something Sweet in Your Inbox

Join the bakery list for seasonal flavors, holiday preorder dates, Cedar Key events, and fresh-from-the-oven news.

Only needed if you would like text updates.